Calvin Klein dropped a new “Feel the Fit” campaign Tuesday starring Sadie Sink, and the internet did what the internet does: immediately started comparing it to last year’s Sydney Sweeney American Eagle fiasco.
Sink, who spent years getting tossed around by Vecna on Stranger Things and is now playing Jean Grey in the Marvel universe (yes, the pun writes itself), appears in a 30-second spot wearing the brand’s 90s Straight Jean. The video starts with her in a white tank and CK underwear in a kitchen. She puts the jeans on. Then the faucet goes haywire, water sprays everywhere, a toaster apparently explodes, and soap foam starts flooding the floor like someone left the dishwasher running during a flood. She just stands there wet, looking unbothered, and walks off down the hallway. The tagline is “in the perfect fit, nothing else matters.”
There’s another clip where she’s dancing around a bedroom with a hairbrush microphone to Willa Ford’s “I Wanna Be Bad.” Peak early-2000s energy. It’s horny in that classic Calvin Klein way without being cartoonish.
Compare that to the 2025 American Eagle campaign that turned Sydney Sweeney into a national conversation piece. AE went with “Sydney Sweeney has great jeans,” a pun that some people heard as “great genes.” Sweeney, blonde and blue-eyed, delivered a little monologue about how genes get passed down and determine hair color, personality, and eye color before landing on “My jeans are blue.”
Half the internet called it a eugenics dog whistle. The other half said everyone needed to touch grass and that it was just a jeans ad featuring a very attractive woman. President Trump weighed in. Doja Cat made a parody. American Eagle’s stock moved. Sales apparently didn’t. The whole thing became a proxy war about race, beauty standards, and whether ads are allowed to be sexy anymore.
Calvin Klein has been in this game a lot longer. Their 1980 Brooke Shields campaign (“Nothing comes between me and my Calvins”) was already controversial when Shields was 15. They’ve spent decades selling denim with half-naked people and zero interest in explaining themselves. The Sadie Sink spot feels like a return to that formula: pretty girl, good lighting, wet tank top, jeans that actually look like jeans. No genetics lecture. No billboard correction from “genes” to “jeans.”
Just the product and the implication that putting them on changes your whole vibe.
People are already lining up the two campaigns like it’s a versus battle. One side says Sink’s ad is classier and less try-hard. The other side is just happy another actress they grew up watching is now in underwear on camera. Both takes are valid in the current economy.
Calvin Klein didn’t invent the formula. They just refuse to stop using it. And after last year’s circus, they probably figured the safest move was to skip the wordplay and let the jeans (and the redhead wearing them) do the talking. So far it seems to be working. No one’s accusing anyone of promoting selective breeding. They’re just watching the video on loop. That’s probably the win.
A note on comments: Our advertisers enforce a strict zero-tolerance policy on racism, hate speech, and threats of violence. Any comment that crosses that line will be removed and the account permanently banned — no warnings. Debate hard, but keep it civil.
A note on comments: Our advertisers enforce a strict zero-tolerance policy on racism, hate speech, and threats of violence. Any comment that crosses that line will be removed and the account permanently banned — no warnings. Debate hard, but keep it civil.